- Born: 3 Feb 1792, New Jersey
- Marriage (1): Matthew McNinch on 23 Feb 1816 in Conesus, New York
- Died: 11 May 1863 at age 71
- Buried: Union Society graveyard in the SW part of Conesus, Livingston County, N.Y.
Sarah Coller's gravestone reads:
wife of Mathew McNinch
May 11, 1863
Aged 71 Yr 3 mo.
& 8 ds.
Sarah and Matthew Mcninch moved to Conesus, New York in 1806 from Pennsylvania.
Sarah married Matthew McNinch, son of Patrick McNinch and Jane, on 23 Feb 1816 in Conesus, New York. (Matthew McNinch was born on 3 Mar 1784 in Pennsylvania, died on 18 Mar 1867 and was buried in Union Society graveyard in the SW part of Conesus, Livingston County, N.Y..)